So, you’ve finally decided you’re heading to the Hawaiian Islands for your vacation. Now, the only thing left to do is figure out which one is right for you! While it’s true, there’s no wrong choice, to help you weigh your options, we’re doing a deep dive into two of our favorites: Kauai vs Maui. From the top outdoor activities to unique adventures and everything in between, it’s all here. Check it out and start dreaming up your perfect Hawaiian getaway today!
Never miss an update on sales, special properties, or other important Suite Paradise news.
SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER TODAY!
Kauai vs Maui - The Basics
Before we dive into the differences between Kauai and Maui, let’s cover the basics. Regardless of your destination, you’re in for miles of beaches, exceptional scenery, delicious food, and unique cultural sights.
Kauai
Kauai is the oldest and fourth-largest island in the Hawaiian chain. Nicknamed the “Garden Isle,” it’s covered in gorgeous rainforests, towering cliffs, and deep valleys with cascading waterfalls and many areas that are only accessible by air or boat. As it’s less touristy than Maui, you can enjoy a calm island getaway that prioritizes connecting with nature and enjoying the peace of a tropical retreat.
Maui
Maui is both the second-largest and the second-most-visited island in Hawaii. Full of everything you could want on an island vacation, it offers the perfect blend of action and relaxation. The beaches are covered in beautiful golden sand, perfect for days spent sunbathing or splashing in the waves. And because it’s more populated, there are numerous excursion companies available to make all your adventure dreams a reality.
What Kind of Vacation is Calling to You?
Outdoor Adventures
If connecting with nature is at the top of your vacation to-do list, then the less crowded island of Kauai is right for you. Here, you can visit Waimea Canyon, also known as the Grand Canyon of the Pacific, and take in stunning views of the colorful gorge. Kayak along the Wailua River, Polynesia’s only navigable stream. Or book a helicopter tour and soar over the dense forest canopy and past the rugged Na Pali Coast. With fewer people, you’re able to unplug and lean into the natural beauty of the island.
In Maui, while there are still loads of outdoor adventures, you may find yourself on crowded trails and at overly populated “secret” spots. However, even with the crowds, things like sunrise at Haleakala National Park atop a massive dormant volcano, hiking through the Iao Valley, or driving along the scenic Road to Hana are still wildly worth it.
Beaches
This one is a tricky comparison because whether you’re looking at Kauai or Maui, there’s no shortage of easily accessible, swimmable beaches. What you have to ask yourself, in that case, is what kind of beach activities you want. If snorkeling and whale watching are important, then Maui wins hands-down. Especially if you’re visiting in the winter months when the humpback whales have migrated to Hawaii.
You can book incredible boat tours with PacWhale Eco-Adventures, where a certified marine naturalist takes you on a two-hour educational expedition. From Kihei to North Shore, Maui’s beaches are some of the most popular in the world.
In Kauai, places like Poipu Beach, Haena Beach, and Lydgate Beach still shine bright with beautiful blue water, gentle waves, and plenty of swimming options. And if you’ve booked one of our Suite Paradise Poipu oceanfront vacation rentals, you can walk right out your door and be at the beach in minutes.
Off the Beaten Path Activities
The Culinary Market | Kaua'i
Indulge in the local fare and delicacies at the Kauai Culinary Market, which is located in The Shops at Kukuiula. Every Wednesday from 3:30 to 6 pm., enjoy the sounds of live music filling the air as you meander through manicured landscape at this beloved shopping center. Local farmers, small businesses, and artisans proudly offer their best selection of fresh, locally grown produce, pies, jams, and other food products. You'll even have the opportunity to watch live cooking demonstrations from South Shore chefs at the Wine and Beer Garden. We invite you to attend!
Hanalei Town | Kaua'i
One of the best parts of visiting a new place is getting to immerse yourself in the local culture and discover new things. And in Kauai’s Hanalei Town, you can do just that. Located on the north shore, this charming community has everything from historic sites to thriving art galleries full of works made by native Hawaiians. It’s also a popular spot for ukulele concerts held at the Hanalei Community Center.
Kilohana Plantation | Kaua'i
For more cultural immersion in Kauai, the Kilohana Plantation gives visitors a glimpse into the island's farming past and cultural roots. It’s also home to a rum distillery and tasting room! Visitors can enjoy a train ride through the grounds or opt for the Rum Safari ride, which leads you through the gardens and introduces you to exotic fruits and plants. There’s also a nightly Luau, which features a classic Hawaiian dinner, fire dancers, hula, and incredible theatrics. They have several event packages, so you can customize your visit.
Hidden Gems | Maui
In Maui, some top recommended unique activities include catching a Big Wave surfing competition in North Shore, where the waves can reach upwards of 60 feet, visiting ancient temple ruins at Kahanu Garden, or checking out the island’s oldest history museum at the Bailey House.
Each island has secrets and treasures waiting to be discovered. Spend some time in locally owned shops, make friends with the people who live here, and see how many gems you can add to this list.
Restaurants, Shopping, and Nightlife | Kaua'i & Maui
When it comes to variety and the sheer number of available options, Maui beats Kauai in this category. However, what Kauai lacks in bars, breweries, and shopping, it makes up for in its food scene. From fresh poke to fine dining, you can satisfy your every craving.
Places like Table at Poipu or La Spezia are focused on delivering elevated dishes that pay tribute to old-world techniques and bright, fresh ingredients. Meaning, if you’re a foodie, there really is only one choice when it comes to Kauai vs Maui.
That doesn’t mean you won’t find fantastic food in Maui. There are myriad places like Mama’s Fish House, Spago, and Duke’s that will leave you craving more.
When you’re in need of some retail therapy on Maui, Whalers Village and the Shops at Wailea are full of local and national brands. And those who crave nightlife can enjoy a thriving bar scene as well.
Book Your Dream Hawaiian Vacation
As you finalize your decision on which island is right for you, be sure to remember the most important rule of Hawaiian travel: Book your vacation rental directly with a local property manager!
Not only will you receive the best rate on your rental, but you’ll also avoid the hassle of dealing with a third party who has likely never even been to Hawaii. Our team of on-island professionals is available to assist you every step of the way, from booking through to check-out. So whether you’re choosing a peaceful garden-view beach rental in Kauai or a beachfront property in Maui, our team is available to help.
Suite Paradise invites you to browse all our available Kauai rentals as well as our sister company, I Go Maui’s rentals, and book your trip directly with us today!